In church this morning, I just heard the founder of the Hope Center talk about helping poor kids in North Omaha become employable and have more hope for their future. It sounded like a great program. They tutored kids to get caught up in school. They had art and athletic programs. He gave statistics about how the kids in their program had much higher graduation rates, they got steady jobs. They had futures and a sense of community, where before their only safety was in gang life.
But my question is, why are Christians so likely to be conservative and vote against social programs - like this one - when the government does it, but support it when the church does it? Could it be that they don't actually want to help people, so much as propagate their beliefs and feel good about their generosity?
If we wanted to help lift people out of poverty, we would want such social programs to be available to all children - without religious strings attached. If we wanted such a society, we would vote for government officials who would help shape such a society. Instead, Christians are notoriously conservative. And increasingly I've been finding the fundamental views of conservatism to be "personal responsibility." (Which roughly translates to, "if you're poor, then you're on your own." or "You're not getting any of my money." or "I WORK for my money (even though I had rich white parents who put me through college and I have a cushy desk job that pays 6 figures, while you work twice as many hours a week at crappy hourly jobs, trying to save enough money to go to a community college), so I don't give out handouts.")
{Since we all know that poverty is a hole that's nearly impossible to dig yourself out of. You can't go to college unless you can afford to pay the college bills, and pay the rent while you're studying - which you can't do unless you have a high-paying job - which you can't get unless you have a college degree - which you can't get unless.... Ad infinitum}
But then when a program like this comes into their church, they all feel bad for the poor little black children in North Omaha, without a dad to come see their football games. And then they want to help - but only when it comes by way of a preacher not a politician, and only when they don't actually have to get involved, and only when it doesn't raise their taxes or make them uncomfortable, and only when they can feel really really good about themselves for putting five dollars in the offering bucket. Is that really what Jesus would have wanted?
I think we need to focus on actually building a better society, not doing temporary fixes that either a) make us feel good about ourselves or b) propagate our beliefs, with the goal of making everybody just like us. (The Ann Coulter effect; in a perfect world, everyone would be a white, middle class Christian conservative American.)
I think that the Hope Center is a great program. I think that their tutoring and arts programs, their focus on employability - these things are definitely needed. Sometimes I'm just uncertain of how we get there, and how pure our motives are.
Really, I'm always amazed at the disconnect between Christian "selfless generosity for those in need" and "the servant's heart," and Christian "you're on your own" conservative politics. If Christians really had a servant's heart, would that not show through in their voting record?
Sunday, May 23, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
11 comments:
this is an interesting thing to point out. I agree with you, but I think I can shed some light on the mindset for you.
the reason that Conservative Christians don't like government programs to help people is that they think that helping people is the church's work. which would be all well and good, if the church did enough. the trouble is that it doesn't, if the church were doing enough to help people there would be no need for government programs to do the same, they would be redundant. but that's not the world we live in.
in my experience though, many conservatives like to base their policy on a "perfect" world scenario, and not on anything substantial or physical. which is a non-functional system when the world does not match up with the ideal of a "perfect" world. (I use quotes to acknowledge that not everyone's idea of a perfect world is the same.)
anyway, I'm going to stop before I get on anymore of a rant.
good blog, keep going, I (and many others) will enjoy this I think.
I think that doing things based on what a "perfect" world should be is dangerous. In a "perfect" world politicians wouldn't lie, people wouldn't need government programs and all news stations would be unbiased. So to support the church and not the government because you wish the world were perfect isn't helping - it's hindering. So this is a good point that you bring up.
So how do we get people to wake up?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CUfaJ8RqfOg
I agree with you JD, and with most of the comments posted here. But I think I can add something to your understanding. There is an element of fear of government in the conservative mindset,and it's not without basis. There is a story of Stalin explaining how he kept in power by making the people dependent upon him. He said something like - Hold a bird too loosely and it will escape. Hold it too tightly and your will kill it. But if you pluck every feather from it, the bird will be be unable to fly, and will sit quietly in your hand, grateful for its warmth. That is why conservatives hate to see people become dependent upon government.
That's a good point, Barry. And was it Thomas Jefferson who said, "A government big enough to give you everything you want is big enough to take away everything you have.”
And I can understand that fear, I suppose. I've read 1984. But for me, I have more a trust in our elected government than I do in for-profit corporations. Which is why I think a socialized health care system would be better than an insurance system that acts as a middle-man, skimming people's money off the top, and denying people coverage when it can save their profit-margin.
The way I see it, the only way our system can remain free is to have a balance of power. Something needs to keep the government from being too powerful, but something also needs to keep the corporate world from being too powerful, because corporations can have just as much influence over our lives, it seems.
If we have too weak of a government, then what protection do we, as individuals, have over corporate interests wanting to prey on us? I mean, Thomas Jefferson also said, "Experience demands that man is the only animal which devours his own kind, for I can apply no milder term to the general prey of the rich on the poor. "
Capitalism, in its pure unbridled state, does seem to make poor into dirt that rich men can take root in, drawing up their nutrients through the crumpled bits of broken men.
To be more clear (which I suppose I should be), the government has given the individual many protections from corporate abuse -- minimum wage laws, the creation of the 40 hour work week, OSHA, child labor laws, etc. To keep us from working 12 hour days in dangerous sweat shops for a dollar a day.
And then they have consumer protections, like the FDA, to keep rat bits from rotting in our hamburger.
These things may not be perfect, but they seem a whole lot better than no protection at all.
But I can certainly understand this fear, which is why I am so vigilant for things like the Patriot Act, and this movement by conservatives to not read Miranda Rights to terrorist suspects (even the ones who are American citizens), the detainments happening at Guantanamo Bay. These are ways that the government is actively eroding our protections as citizens FROM the reach of the government -- and they're all being done at the hands of conservatives.
I'm far less worried about my tax dollars going to help a poor person start a business than I am about the government not needing a warrant to tap my phone, or being able to hold me, indefinitely, without charge if they "suspect" that I'm a terrorist. Because, with vague terminology like that, and no balance of power to protect me, none of the miranda rights in place, what's to stop the government from being able to throw any of us in prison, if we become "inconvenient." It's a much more real and present danger than us getting too dependent on a health care system that covers all citizens equally. I mean, isn't it?
Replace "communist" with "terrorist" and we could have the McCarthy era all over again. Replace "witch" with "terrorist" and it'll be the Salem Witch Trials.
You use the term balance. We always need a balance between government control and personal freedom. And we are constantly renegotiating that balance point.
The power grab during the Bush administration was interesting because so few conservatives rose up in opposition. If a Democrat president had done the same things there would have been a revolution. That was in response to 911 and we relinquished freedom, giving more power to the government. Now, in response to another emergency, a new administration is reaching for new powers. As the government takes greater control of the economy, some people will give up some of their power. They showed they were unworthy of the power, so they will loose some. Not enough to stop it all from happening again, but the government will gain some power. That's the way it works. Every administration will use whatever chances present themselves to increase their power. It's all about that balance of power between government control and personal freedom.
But we don't discuss it that way. Neither our politicians or the media that cover them are good at balance. Extremes divide people and get them fired up, giving politicians more power, and extremes make better show business and earn better ratings. There is no reward on either side for finding balance and solving problems.
I see your point, except that I would maintain that the balance of power isn't strictly between the government and the individual, but a ménage à trois between government, big business, and the individual.
Let's look at the coal mining industry for an example. Big business, unchecked, throws safety - and the lives of its expendable workers - to the wind for increased profits. (Because the business exists solely for that purpose; profit.)
When the government comes in and fines the business, or closes down mines that aren't in compliance -- is that a government exercise of it's power over the individual? Is it limiting personal freedoms? I would argue that it is stepping in and defending the freedoms of the individual.
If there is a sufficiently high pool of unemployed, the individual worker has no leverage against a big business. At most, he can quit. Big deal, they'll hire another worker. Maybe even start the new guy off for lower wages. Win-win.
Individual workers can band together into a union. But history shows that strikes can end in bloodshed. There's always the risk of lost wages, lost jobs, etc. It's a much more dangerous endeavor - and that discourages many workers from stepping out of line in defense of their safety and standard of living.
And there's a history leading from textile mills and before to the current day where workers had to fight to get a fair standard of living, and fair working conditions, from the companies that profited off of them.
The government is like the union representing the entire nation. When there are unsafe or unethical business practices, the government is the only entity with enough power to step in *in defense of* the individual's freedom.
(Barry, I keep rebutting your comments not because I don't think they're brilliant observations, but because I want to give you fuel to keep going. Just so you know.)
Post a Comment