The BP oil spill in the gulf coast is a tremendous disaster, both environmentally and economically for the people and communities depending on the coast.
I've listened in horror to the news reports on NPR, with attempt after attempt failing to stop the flow of oil. The statements that it might not get plugged until they can dig a relief well - a process that won't be completed until August.
It's easy, now that there's been a gaping wound in the crust of the earth for over 40 days now, to look back in hindsight and say that things haven't been handled properly.
While this may be true, and thinking about how to handle things properly is a worthwhile pursuit, I think there are some serious dangers to this kind of thinking, as well. I think we, as a nation, tend to be monday morning quarterbacks. It's easy for us to look back and say, "Well, this is a huge disaster, the President should have done more to stop it. It doesn't seem like he's doing very much."
Well, there are two points: 1) You, a lay person in the middle of farm country, U.S.A., really have no idea what the President is doing.
2) You, with your expert in farm equipment maintenance, would be hard pressed to know the first step to handling a huge crisis like this. So, I'd like to see you do better.
When that oil platform first exploded, my thought was horror at the loss of life. 11 men died. That's tragic. I didn't immediately think, "There's no way they'll be able to cap this spill! Let's start building 100 miles of sand barriers to protect our coast line!" No one knew the scale that this would become. So, yeah, maybe Obama hasn't handled this like he could have, but I think it's ridiculous to expect a man, just because he's the President, to never make a mistake when he's thrown such a monumental curve ball.
So, to all these polls showing that a majority of the country thinks that Obama's not doing enough to stop the oil spill, I would question where you formed that belief. Is it because he hasn't been impassioned enough in his speaking? Or because BP hasn't found a way to fix their problem yet? Or because Obama hasn't kicked them aside from their area of expertise in order to tinker with it? Or because he didn't know 40 days ago that he'd need to build barrier islands?
I'm just afraid that it's all politicized spin.
That said, I think we should look more carefully about the future of offshore drilling, and be more prepared for disasters like this in the future.
I think we need to look carefully at the financial relationship between big energy businesses and the government. A coworker shared with me his belief that the government will never harshly discipline an oil business, or enact laws that don't favor big oil, because politicians get so much money from oil businesses for their campaigns. Is this a bribe, when it really comes down to it? And is this in the best interest of the people?
I think it'll be interesting to see what, if any, money BP gives back to the communities and fishermen that are affected by their follies.
But, I think we should judge Obama more on his policies than on this misguided assumption that he should have fixed this disaster by now.
Sunday, May 30, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Quick update, after listening to today's "On Point" on NPR.
-There is no easy fix for the well. If they plug the leak, the pressure underneath could cause the sea bed to become a crater, spewing oil even more uncontrollably from numerous cracks. So, the real question for right now is how to best contain the oil until they can relieve pressure.
-One panelist made the point that the President should take control, not because he has more expertise, but because BP is a for-profit company, which means that their interests are in their bottom line and their reputation. The government exists for the public, not for profit, so they could make sure that BP is using all of their resources for the purpose of stopping this disaster.
-One panelist made the point that BP is doing all they can to stop the leak (that's in their interest), but where they fall short is in cleanup and containment. That's where she proposed that the government should step in.
Any thoughts?
Post a Comment