Hello!

Welcome to my blog. Although it is called "Angry Hooton," I will try not to be so. This is a place for me to question politics, religion, and philosophy. If it sounds like I have the answers, I don't - I'm trying to find them. And if you can help steer me along the way, I will much appreciate it. Come with an open mind, and kind words.

Thursday, November 4, 2010

When is an artist an artist?

I'm going to stray from my usual political rantings here for some quiet reflection on the arts. Seriously.

The wife and I were out recently with some friends of ours, an extremely talented photographer and his lovely and talented girlfriend. We, being new and aspiring photographers, enjoyed the conversation, which invariably turned to the business of photography.

The comment was raised that one of the problems with the photography industry is that anyone can buy a nice camera and say that they're a photographer. This causes an over-saturation of photographers in the market. "Fake" photographers undercut prices of highly trained photographers. Then the client in your office is saying they don't understand WHY in the world YOUR photography costs so much when so-and-so says he'll do it for $60 bucks.

I've thought a lot about that comment since then, because I have very mixed feelings about it. First off, it's definitely true. There's an over-saturation of crap photographers. And there are a whole lot of people that spend some money on a camera and think that they're creating art. And it's really easy to get bitter about that. Especially when you see clients walk out your door and hire a "crap photographer" over you.

But then you have to ask yourself, "Well, who defines what art is? Maybe the client actually LIKES their photography."

And on top of that, "Well, isn't that exactly how I started out? Wasn't I just a guy with a camera once? Who got to decide when I was good enough to be 'pro'?"

And on top of that even, "Why do I get to pass judgment on these photographers? Isn't there always some amazingly talented photographer out there who is better than me, who could say that I'M not really an artist? That I'm just an amateur hack clogging up the industry?"


It's an interesting dilemma. I've had the same questions. What is the difference between your uncle taking a snapshot of your birthday party and the photos I take? Who decides which is art? There are photojournalists who argue that the raw, real moment is the art. There are photoshoppers who say it's not art unless you've spent 13 hours in post production. Who's to say they're not both right?

I've always said this about music: It doesn't matter how much training you have, or how technically proficient you are - there's a whole separate quality that makes it art. Which is why I can't stand Steve Vai (who is a wonderfully talented guitarist), and I love Damien Rice (who is a moderately talented guitarist at best.) It's not a question of skill or technique - those things are cold, lifeless tools. It's a question of art.

But art is entirely subjective. What one person adores, another could find contrived, boring, lifeless, dull, cheesy, or any number of adjectives. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, as they say.


Another good friend of mine said something like this (this is a gross paraphrase): "It's a fallacy that 'there's not enough to go around.' Go out and do what you love and you will succeed."

I think that, in the arts in general, it doesn't help us to point to the newbs who are just starting out and learning and enjoying their new passion and blame them for destroying the industry (even if there is some truth to it.) We should help them along their journey, because no matter how good they get, they will never be us. They will never have our eyes. Our brains. Their art will always be different. As Victor Wooten said about bass playing, "You could put a newborn baby on the instrument and they'll be able to get sounds I can't produce."



The real problem is with the consumer! They're the ones who keep hiring these fools. Okay, I'm joking. But at the same time, I'm not.

A client who has no photographic training (or musical training) may not be able to see the minute differences in lighting, post production, depth of field, exposure, etc. - the same way that the general listener doesn't understand the way a dominant 7 chord resolves down to the tonic in such a beautifully elegant way.

They just know what they like. They know when they see a picture and it affects them emotionally. They don't know why, and they don't care. They only care about the impact on them.


Whew. My big conclusion (after reading The Fountainhead a few years back) is that as an artist, you make art. Most people might not like your work - they don't matter. There may be thousands of other people doing it differently - they don't matter. What matters is you, and your art. You are the creator.

Some people will like what you do, and those people will find you.

3 comments:

Russ Beye said...

I used to have aggressive thoughts about this in the past. I mean, if I am the one doing it, then I must be part of the "real" crowd that gets it, right? Well, wrong actually. Yes, you see your photography as a business, an endeavor, but that does not mean that anybody else who goes out and buys a $500 or more camera is not a real photographer... Or crap for that matter. It's different aspirations and goals. Your pictures, which are very well composed, suit a specific need in the photo industry. Romantic, artistic, and intimate moments are what you do. The guy down the street might just have the goal of archiving memories in anyway he can, oh, and he likes nice things. The consumer is who decides what needs are to be served in any industry. If you find that your potential clientele think you are expensive, then ask "What are you expecting from the shoot, and what are you willing to pay?" I think, and this is coming from actual small business experience, entrepreneurs don't don't ask enough questions from their clients. They have that complex that they already know what's best, I mean… They started the business for that very same reason, right? Rubbish. Get out there and find out exactly who you are targeting, what their motives are, and how much will they spend. You don't set prices, they do.

In the end, it's not always about art or what we think we know is art. Any business is about business. Granted, you gotta love what you do, because I know I can tell the difference from someone that truly believes in what they do versus someone that just wants a buck. If you wish to start a business photographing events, people, whatever… Then remember it's a business, and now money is involved. Your definitions are art take a backseat, because now the customer is telling you what they want and how much they'll pay for it. Now, I can see where telling you it's more about the business can be controversial, but didn't you get upset when people undercut you? Then yes, it is about the business first, art second.

This is long enough, but I can talk all day about this subject… Bottom line, instead of thinking what you like or consider art, think about what the customers want and what they are willing to pay. Then, adjust your goals and marketing to that. If you search Google for "photographers", you get 39.8 million hits. Out of that, how easy is it going to be to find a good wedding photographer? Any one of those could say, "Sure, I can do that!" If you narrow that down to "wedding photographers" you are now at 2.81 million. You will have a better chance of finding a photographer that can see your vision and gets the whole wedding scene.

So the question is, what segment shares your vision?

P.S. Eff Vai, too.

JD Hooton said...

You have some very good points, but I do have one area I disagree with you.

As a photographer or musician, you are an artist. And so, it's not JUST about business, since you are selling art.

You can try to conform to whatever you think people want, but then you could lose all of your uniqueness. What's to separate you from those other millions of photographers out there trying to provide what they think people want?

I mean, you're right, we have to listen to clients and be sure we're meeting their needs and setting prices accordingly. That's definitely true.

But we can't lose our art in the process, either.

JD Hooton said...

See, my problem with the "just do whatever the client wants because the client is always right" mentality is that the client isn't a photographer.

Before this sounds too much like elitist drivel, let me explain.

When Heather and I went to get flowers for our wedding, we had no idea what we were doing. We came to this professional and told him vague things like, "Antique, dusty colors..." and he was able to understand the vagueness of what we thought we wanted, and suggest colors and textures that fulfilled what we wanted.

So, yes, we need to listen to the client. But the client isn't a photographer. They don't know the tools we use to achieve the goal. They just have a vague impression of how they want the end result to look. And usually they describe it with vague terms like, "classy" or "dramatic." Which we have to interpret into, "Hard directional light from the side, with a 3:1 fill ratio, with the camera at this angle, with a shallow depth of field, and..."

So, once again, we have to listen to the client and make sure they get what they want - but what makes a photographer succeed is his ability to take these requests from the client and turn them into art.


We keep hiring Daniel Muller whenever we need pictures. It's not because he's the best business man in the world. It's because every time he takes pictures, he captures the moments we want him to and elevates them into art.