Hello!

Welcome to my blog. Although it is called "Angry Hooton," I will try not to be so. This is a place for me to question politics, religion, and philosophy. If it sounds like I have the answers, I don't - I'm trying to find them. And if you can help steer me along the way, I will much appreciate it. Come with an open mind, and kind words.

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Abortion Introduction

In the next several posts, I'm going to be explaining my views on abortion. This is not an easy discussion for me to approach, because I do not see the issue as black and white. If you see abortion as the murder of a human being with a soul, it's impossible for me to change your mind. And I'm not going to try to change your mind. What I am going to try to do is explain how someone else can see it differently, so that you can gain understanding.

If you are a person who believes strongly in the the other direction - that a woman has a right to make decisions about what happens to her own body and that is final - please try to understand how the other side can see it. That abortion is simply a selfish way to remove the negative consequences of sexual choices by ending a life.

What I ask is that we all approach this subject with an open mind and respect.

If you believe that abortion is immoral, I'm not going to ask you to change your mind, to have abortions of your own, or perform abortions, or recommend abortions. I would perhaps like you to come to the realization that pro-choice doesn't equal pro-death. That we're all pro life, in different ways. That it isn't helpful to vilify the opposing belief.

What I am going to explain is my stance that you can disapprove of something without trying to make everyone else in the country follow your belief. I'm going to be echoing some of the statements I made in previous posts about The Separation of Church and State. My stance is that abortion is a continuum of shades of grey. That shades of grey should always be left up to the discretion of the individual. And that forcing other people to follow your personal convictions through legislating morality really limits all of our freedom to have our own beliefs.

So, take a deep breath, get a fresh cup of coffee. Let's begin.

8 comments:

Unknown said...

I have read through these posts several times now and what makes it so frustrating is that you are such a good writer, JD, really. One could easily read through these posts and just agree because it sounds well thought out. One could also read it and be sick with sadness because they know it's not quite right but can't pinpoint why or say it as eloquently as you have and end up saying nothing for fear of looking like a simple, old-fashioned fool.

I have always admired your (& Heather's) desire and ability to understand where other people are coming from. I think that is SO important when dealing with difficult issues. This understanding of each other helps us not be so judgmental of each other and get mean when we argue. It allows us to give each other grace, to forgive. HOWEVER, I believe that you can go to an extreme in wanting to understand where everyone is coming from that you end up not having any beliefs, nothing to stand on, NO TRUTH. Truth is not truth because the majority believes it to be true. Truth is truth because it is TRUE. Regardless of religion or politics or whatever the "government" (whoever that is) says is legal or what feels good or what an individual decides is right for them. We have to be able to challenge one another to live by what is true.

It made a lot of sense when you said in the Facebook post that your "view" of the world and the government is a fluid thing, shifting with new information and new perspectives. You seem to be guarding yourself from having any beliefs...only views. I can't expect these posts of your views to make complete sense. They are like branches of a tree that have no trunk, no roots. They are very pretty, some even have flowers...oooo. But they will wither and blow away if they are not grounded in Truth.

If I can get the kids to nap at the same time today I plan to go through each post and point out the things that do not make sense and hopefully discuss the absence of roots and "Truth" and what that might mean for us individually and as a society. Please know JD that if I did not love you I would not be spending my time with all of this.

Tory said...

Ok JD I have a challenge for you for “abortion 6.” First off let me say that I am happy that you are asking these questions, and you make some good points especially about trying to look at another's view point with understanding rather then jumping to criticism or even, as sadly is the case too often on both sides, with hate.

I would love to see your defense of these thoughts expand a bit... I gather from your posts that you are questioning the wisdom that your upbringing has taught you, which was from a religious standpoint. I think that is great and a perfectly reasonable thing to do. But from what I can tell, correct me if I am wrong, the basis for your conclusions is the tenant of protecting personal freedoms... I would like to see you expand your ideas and broaden the support for your ideas to include a bit more.

I understand the mistrust of just going with your religious or family upbringing. Making decisions only on these grounds leads to blind trust and turning off logic in the face of emotional reactions. I would challenge you then, to go back further than your family and even further than the religion of your upbringing (even though I think that there is not a dichotomy with religion and logic, but that is for another time) and I would ask you to defend or explain your ideas on the basis of Goodness, Beauty and Truth. This is the basis of all western thought and the standard test of the author of one of your favorite quotes “the unexamined life is not worth living” - Socrates.

I would hope that we could agree that in an ideal situation we would make decisions and policies, and as authors and teachers spur each other on to Goodness, Beauty and Truth. I would also hope that we would agree that while personal freedom is important and worth fighting for that it is not the trump card over Goodness, for example my personal freedom should not cause you harm.

So I would love to see you work through why these changes would be in the best interest for Goodness, Beauty and Truth for individuals and society as a whole... then I think we can start a conversation on the topic that will be truly meaningful.

I would also like to challenge you to work a bit harder... It is a common, and even a bit fun thing, to point out complexities and “gray areas” but it is harder, and much more useful to drill into issues and point out where the gray areas are and where they would become solid. Or in what context they would be solid.

If you work out these issues asking how they work into Beauty, Truth, and Goodness, and also work out what it might take to make clear decisions in specific contexts and where it is not possible to make clear decisions. Then I think we have the basis for a real philosophical discussion.

JD Hooton said...

Annie, I must say, I take some exception to your implication that I have no beliefs and no truth to stand on.

While I am making a point to steer clear of my religious beliefs as basis for legislation (because this is the only way to protect all of us, and our freedom to hold our beliefs), I would hardly say that I have no beliefs at all.

My belief is that any time we legislate based on religious beliefs, it weakens freedom itself. It puts us in danger of having our beliefs and our way of live put on the chopping block.

When I said my beliefs are a fluid thing, I did not mean that I have no beliefs. I mean that I approach my beliefs like a scientist. I pose a theory, and test it. If evidence can be introduced that shows my theory to be false, then I am compelled to change my belief. But that does not mean that the belief I hold has no truth. It means that I do not believe that I currently am conscious of ALL truth, or am in a position to tell other people that my idea of truth is the only truth. What I mean when I say that it is fluid is that I am humble enough to know I might be wrong. But that doesn't mean that my beliefs are just wild guesses with no foundation.

And, Tory, you ask me to consider what is beautiful, good, and true. I believe that what makes America great, and what makes this life beautiful is our freedom. There may not be anything inherently beautiful in eating at McDonald's or smoking a cigarette, but I do believe there is something sublime in the fact that we have that choice. The freedom of choice means that sometimes we will make wrong decisions. But it is still more good and beautiful that we have the choice to begin with.

You also ask me to consider what would need to know to make clear decisions on this "grey area." I would suggest that the great questions for abortion are when a life becomes a life, and whether it has a soul. The problem is that these answers are different depending on your religious beliefs. An atheist might say, "It is a life when it has consciousness. When it has the ability to suffer. Or when it has the ability to sustain its own life outside of the womb." Clearly this would be different from the religious opinion that life begins at conception, when God implants the cell with an eternal soul. And which answer is right is purely a subjective, personal decision, based on the beliefs of the decider. Unless we can prove the existence of a soul, or of God, and prove which god is the right god, these are not provable things. They are left open to belief and faith. Once again, I'll make the point that some people believe it to be sinful even to try to prevent pregnancy - through condoms, contraceptives and the like - because it stands in the way of God's will. And it may be difficult to tell them that their view of truth is wrong - but do you want them telling you that you must follow their view of truth in your own life, simply because they believe it to be true?

My point is that I don't believe that it can be a clear decision. And I believe that the upholding of personal freedoms of belief and choice is more important and more practical than trying to make that decision for everybody.

Tory said...

I would suggest that it is not freedom for freedom’s sake that people have put their lives on the line for this country but the idea that we are all free to seek happiness and live out our convictions. By your own logic then the government should not do anything that would impose an ideology or infringe on your right to make decisions the way you would like. So social justice causes should be out, because that is the government regulating that I spent some of my money on helping the poor... what if I don’t want to? what if I don’t want to help build roads or maintain an army? or pay for someone else's education? This is not really a choice I can make...

We will disagree on this philosophical point, I guess, but I would in no way hold personal freedom in such high regard. Where is the sense of self sacrifice or honor or duty? These are things that make our country much more beautiful then the ABILITY to smoke in a McDonald’s parking lot.

I am not in any way saying that freedom is not to be fought for but it is not the highest good that our society has and it is trumped all the time by other considerations.

You are right that sometimes we will get it wrong but that is also how we are able to change things. But my point is that there are many times that we can not hold personal freedoms as the highest gauge for our decisions.

As to the “gray issue” I think that it is not so much a religious consideration as a question of logically looking for a few tenants that I think should help set in place policy's on things like this.

1. Is it the best for Human Rights. this includes your precious and “sublime” personal freedom but it also includes what is best for my fellow man even if it means a sacrifice for me personally or as a society.

2. What is the Most Natural Choice. this one might be a harder sell but it just makes logical sense, to me anyway:) The most natural choice is almost always the cheapest the most sustainable and the most eco friendly. It is also arguably the choice that will be the best for all the humans as it will likely lead to health and happiness.

3. Does it lead to a more full human experience. this one is last on the list because it has the most of my personal philosophy in it but I still think that it makes logical sense. we should protect the fullness of human experience and at least try to spur each other on to a full and rich human life. this is because we should care about each other.

To me this would lead us to not make abortion illegal necessarily, but to put our efforts into other solutions, natural family planing, education, adoption, and to your question of who is going to pay for this child born to the poor family I have two things to say.

1. this is not really the problem right now. there is actually more of a problem of poor families having kids to get the government help.

2. one could argue that if it is mainly the poor “needing” abortions because they can not take care of their kids and a higher percentage of the poor are minorities that this is a huge and quiet genocide with the rich white leaders doing nothing to educate or help out the poor. To me that is more of a humans rights violation than an argument for funding to even make abortions possible.

I would agree that we need to be careful what we expect the government to do. It is always dangerous to push responsibility for anything important let alone morality, into the hands of an abstract idea (that is a really nerdy joke by the way) but what I am more concerned with is the philosopher that is writing these posts than the actual civil out workings. When we talk and write about these things I think it is important to have higher ideas then personal freedom... but that is just me.

JD Hooton said...

Tory,

You raise some interesting points. And it's a very interesting point that a true libertarian "freedom-ist" would say the government also shouldn't pay for social programs, because that removes a person's choice whether or not to choose to be charitable. That is what separates me from a full libertarian - because I do believe there are some causes that we should put our collective tax money toward improving. However, there is much debate on how and what we should do to help. Welfare certainly can have negative side effects... but that's a debate for another day.

You say personal freedom isn't the highest good of our country. But I certainly don't see evidence to support your claim that self-sacrifice and duty should replace freedom as the greatest good. Why are those so great? Blind duty causes nationalism without restraint, which is the stuff wars are made of. Self-sacrifice? This makes me think you haven't read The Fountainhead yet. What is so inherently great about a person giving up themselves? Excelling, creating, and achieving - becoming the greatest that a person can be, is that not more beneficial to a society as losing yourself in a sea of others? Why is it best for the individual to cease to be for the sake of everyone else?

I'm not saying that you're wrong, I'm just not following the logic.

I'm also intrigued by your ideas of how we should measure this issue. But, I still don't see where you support your claims here.

It's one thing to say we should look at what is best for human rights, and what leads to the most full human experience - but it's a very different thing to explain why making abortion illegal and dictating, at the government level, what people can do with their reproductive systems is any of those things. I would still argue that the limit of personal freedoms would be an attack on human rights, and that forcing people to behave a certain way is negative for the human experience.

What you're lacking is still an answer to my question. Where does life begin, and does a clump of cells have a soul? If you can prove the point that a one celled organism is a human with a soul, then you're right, this would be a human rights offense! A great genocide! But without making that case first, I don't see the argument.

You say that when we talk about these things, we should have higher ideas than just personal freedom? Well, please, explain what I should be thinking about instead. Because I don't see the virtue of self-sacrifice without a worthy cause. And saying I should self-sacrifice my freedom simply because self-sacrifice trumps freedom seems like a big leap to me.

One thing we do agree on - the statement I've made from the beginning - is that we should be fighting the cause of unwanted pregnancies, rather than just fighting over abortion itself. It was for that reason that I posted my support of Planned Parenthood, because I see them as a great provider of family planning services. And I think it would be a great tragedy to lose their provision of service because of a political squabble over abortion. Like I said to Annie, I believe that removing that service could arguably lead to more abortions, because of the loss of family planning services to reduce the number of unwanted pregnancies.

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Tory said...

Well JD I think we have come down to it... I do not think that self sacrifice for self sacrifice's sake is higher then self freedom. I do not think that duty trumps self freedom by necessity (especially not "blind" duty...way to sneak that in there). These things only point to the higher standard that might make someone limit their own freedom for the sake of another or even an idea... what is this thing?

All I can say is that it is "Virtue" as Socrates points to it is a soul in line with Truth, Beauty and Goodness, this is the reason that Socrates says that "the unexamined life is not worth living..." because that life will not be Virtuous and, as Socrates demonstrated with his own life, he believed that being just in his own soul was worth dying for.

Jesus was another (I would say the ultimate) example of this... giving up his freedom for the good of others...

You may be right that I will not be able to offer arguments that you will be happy with... that is OK. All I can say is that I see the logic of it... I see it with my Mind, My Heart, and my Soul...

This is, I guess, where we differ and I will not at this point try and make you see it my way...

I love you JD and we will talk more about this and other topics soon :)

Unknown said...

Well...my house is as messy as my thoughts right now and I may just have to call this and get back to raising my kids. l know you have beliefs JD. That is made very clear. I question what those beliefs are grounded in? I believe there is such a thing as Truth, not just things that are true or can be proven true by science. It's what allows us to come together and believe in something like liberty and justice for all without needing a scientific argument to uphold such a belief. Is there "proof" of this nature for why you believe in personal freedom or is it something else? Why do you feel compelled to defend it so strongly (at least with words)? Of coarse there is nothing inherently great about a person giving up themselves, that is just suicide. But what is inside the person that sacrifices themselves to uphold Truth (Beauty and Goodness as well)? I would agree with Tory an Socrates and call that Virtue. I don't claim to know what Truth, Beauty, and Goodness are exactly in their purest form and I certainly can't claim to be virtuous in the highest sense of the word, but I would like to strive for these things and I think everyone should.

Though I had planned to go on and post on the rest of your posts, I think it is in the best interest of my family to faze myself out of this discussion. It has already sucked so much time and energy out of the last two days. You say your beliefs are based on testing your own theories like you would science. Well, I certainly hope you never become a scientist JD. I just don't have the time or the patience to search for the evidence that your beliefs in these posts are lacking nor do I have the time or patience to search for the references that you did not site for the evidence you did provide. I realize that means I forfeit our great battle of wits and am now a fool. But alas, I do not care for I have no clean dishes or laundry and my baby is crying (she really doesn't care). :)