So, as I promised, I'm going to make some confessions in this post. There are a great many things that I believe should be legalized. Many of these things are actions that I will never partake in. But I will explain why I don't necessarily support the action itself, I support the legalization of the action.
1. Marijuana.
What is the difference between a legal drug and an illegal drug? If you really think about it, what is the difference? Why do we say that alcohol is legal, that you can buy a great number of pharmaceuticals over the counter or with a prescription, that cigarettes, a known carcinogen, are legal, but we single out a few to say are illegal? Marijuana has no more negative side effects than alcohol, is less addictive and less cancerous than smoking cigarettes, and yet it is singled out to be made illegal. Why?
On top of that, let's look at the consequences. We spend probably in the millions to hunt down druggies and dealers and spend millions more to keep them in jail. On top of that, we give legitimacy to the black market. You don't see people getting shot over alcohol or cigarettes, but it's easy to imagine for the illegal drugs. Don't the negative side effects outweigh the good?
Oh, and what about the positive side effects for legalizing the drug? It could be regulated and controlled, keeping the product safe for consumers. Sales could lead to increased tax revenue.
The main thing is this: I'm opposed to making cigarettes, alcohol, fast food, or deep fried ice cream illegal, too. All things have some sort of side effect that could kill you if not used in moderation. And it's not our place to make such decisions for all people. A person should have absolute control over what he puts into his body, as long as it doesn't endanger those around him.
2. Prostitution
The world's oldest profession, right? It's obviously not going away. People have a strong, biological need for sex. People get lonely. And not everyone believes that sex outside of marriage is wrong. So, what is our justification for making prostitution illegal? Outside of the religious view of sex - how does such a service really differ from a massage, other than the fact that we say it does?
Someone once made the point that getting paid for sex is illegal prostitution. But if you get paid for sex, and film it and sell it, then it's pornography. And that's fine! Why the double standard?
My main concern with prostitution being illegal is, once again, the consequences. We're basically giving pimps and sex-traffickers their jobs. We're legitimizing the black market. We're making it so that prostitutes can't go to the police if they're raped or abused, because they'll just be arrested for their prostitution as well. If it were legal, it could be regulated, clean, and controlled.
3) Gay marriage
I think people should be able to love and marry whoever they want. This is obviously discriminatory to me. And the only justification for the belief in its immorality must be pulled from religious text. This simply has no place in a secular government like ours, because, as I've explained before, it oppresses the beliefs of the non-religious.
Not too long ago, interracial marriages were also illegal. It was illegal based on the belief of that time that it was immoral. I hope all people can now see such legislation as blatant discrimination. And I hope that sometime in the near future, all people will look back on the criminalization of gay marriage with the same sentiment.
Even if your religion teaches you that homosexuality is immoral, that doesn't give you a basis to legislate that belief. Let me ask again - how would you feel if a different group made your marriage illegal? What makes you think that your religious group should have the right to do that to others?
I say all this to try to give you a sense of how I reach conclusions on legislating moral issues. It's not that I would ever hire a prostitute, or that I would try to seek my own gay marriage (I'm already married to a woman), but I look at who it's affecting, I look at the positive and negative side effects. And more often than not, I come to the conclusion that legislation on moral issues either discriminates against differing beliefs, or it causes more harm than good.
Sunday, February 27, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment